Well, folks, now you know why I FINALLY switched my insurance to Mercury (here in California), where by grouping my policies (auto + home), Mercury was able to give me BETTER coverage than State Farm at HALF THE RATE. I kid you not.

Read what RB has had to go through:

Rob,

Friday night, 4:00pm, wife and I notice water outside the front door. After some investigation, determined it was coming from inside a wall in the coat closet, on the other side of the entryway by the front door. At 4:30pm I called my agent who asked if I wanted “Servpro” to come out and do whatever it is they do. I declined saying I’d look into it further. By 5:15pm, we knew we were in over our head. I called and left a message for my agent and then contacted a local flood/restoration company. Naturally, I assumed my HOI would cover a slab leak or at least the ensuing damage. Around 5:30 or so I was on the phone starting the claim process with their claim center. I was told a member of their claims dept should contact me to explain the process within a couple hours. Meanwhile, the flood and restoration company was busy tearing out the wet drywall exposing the leaking pipe. A couple hours later, I initiated a second call. I was greeted by someone who ‘was so glad I called’ and could connect me to the claims department. The claims department indicated they couldn’t authorize any work (I had contacted a local plumber and scheduled him to come out on Saturday morning for repair and/or leak detection) until the damage had been inspected by their adjuster. When I asked when the adjuster would be out, I was told he was off for the weekend and most likely would return my call Monday morning. The claims rep stated that only the adjuster would know my policy and its coverages and exclusions and that the amount of coverage could not be determined without an investigation. I tried my agent again via email and phone, no answer either way. Like a good neighbor, State Farm was…out at the lake fishing or whatever.

Meanwhile, the flood and restoration guy left his blowers blowing and his dehumidifiers dehumidifying.

Saturday morning, the plumber confirms a slab leak but opts not to repair until we discuss with the insurance company. He suspects the leak is about 12” down, below the slab. Neither he nor the flood/restoration guy had EVER heard of a slab leak not being covered. They both indicated, in their experience, that State Farm most likely would not cover repair to the pipe itself, but, based upon what they’ve seen in the past, the insurance normally covers everything else including the drying, wet stuff rip out, slab intrusion, and rebuild. Since State Farm couldn’t tell me what was covered and not, we waited.

Sunday, while waiting, I looked up another local State Farm agent I’d met through the local chamber of commerce. I emailed her. Wouldn’t you know it, she returned my email by calling me within an hour, unlike my own agent.

Monday morning, I finally reach the adjuster. He indicates the field rep is already in the field for the day and won’t be able to assess damage until Tuesday at the earliest. The adjuster indicated that slab leaks are not covered under the policy but that the ensuing damage should be. This meant we would have to pay to cut into the slab and repair the line. At NO time did he mention the infamous ‘subsurface water’ exclusion. I reached my agent on Monday and gave him a piece of my mind. He was less than helpful and claimed to have never received my email. He admitted that he does not check voicemail messages over the weekend. At this point, I’ve made peace with the fact that I’d be paying for my deductible and the plumbing repair in its entirety. I was unsure if the tile damaged to get to the plumbing would be covered or not. Meanwhile, blowers blowing and dehumidifiers dehumidifying

Tuesday morning. The flood and restoration guy arrives and confirms the area is dried. He has done his job correctly and saved our tile from water damage. The State Farm field rep shows up. He does his thing. To his credit, he did the best he could and seemed genuinely empathetic, BUT, wait for it, State Farm has an exclusion for water originating below the surface. If the leak is 12” down, it is below the slab. Therefore, absolutely NOTHING is covered, not the primary event nor the ensuing damage.

In conversations with the adjuster, the agent, and their field rep, they all were adamant that NO ONE covers damage originating from subsurface water and that this is very well known in the industry. To which my flood and restoration guy says, “Uh, no it’s not.” My question, if it’s so well known on their common HOI policy, why the hell didn’t anyone I spoke with when I started the claims process know this??? Had I known on Friday night, I would have told the flood and restoration guy to take a hike and would have gone and rented my own blowers and dehumidifiers from home depot. Since I thought the insurance company was going to cover the loss, I assumed they needed licensed and bonded contractors to do the drying scientifically and not Joe Blow homeowner.

In my opinion, State Farm acted in bad faith by delaying the inspection process and failing to explain the coverage of my HOI policy when I explicitly explained on Friday night that I had a SLAB LEAK. If this exclusion is as well-known as they indicated, certainly their own staff would have known it when the claim was initiated.

They did offer to pay for the leak detection, which I thought was fair considering that $250 got them off the hook for the $3400 drying bill, $3000 rebuild bill, and $900 plumbing repair (more like $2400 because we opted to reroute OUT of the slab).

The ‘good’ news is that my HOI policy is up for renewal in four days. I’m shopping for a new carrier. I wonder if my mortgage company is aware that State Farm lacks this coverage? I wonder if they’d force their homeowners to look for different HOI…

Allen writes:

Hello, I saw your info on-line about Sate Farm. I recently experienced damage to my home due to the heavy snow fall the north east U.S. experienced. Both of the major gutters and the fascia board they attach to are damaged beyond repair and need to be replaced. One fell off the roof completely and the other is barely hanging and is bent beyond recovery. The attic of my house is now exposed to the elements while I await repair. My State Farm agent said the loss would be covered and after waiting 2 weeks for an adjuster I was handed a check for approximately half of what 3 contractors have estimated it would cost.

Rob's reply:

Allen, it's critical that you hand them back the check and submit your own estimates. State Farm relies on "fast pay" to pay out much lower reimbursements. This happened to me with water damage to a floor. Within a day or two, State Farm handed me a check for $6000. Unfortunately, the damage was more than double that amount. I refused the check and submitted estimates from three other vendors, in writing. State Farm revised their check and paid a total of $17K, which did cover the damage.

Never take the quick check. Always do your homework and it should work out.

Everyone knows there's a recession in 2009. Everyone knows that insurance companies are a business. Here's Jerry, who knows it too well:

I just received notice from State Farm they are raising the rates on my property insurance by 57% on one building and 67% on another building. Nothing has changed on any of my property and I have not filed any claims. They just decided they were going to raise the rates.
Who gets away with this kind of outragous price hike?
I wrote to my State insurance commission to see if they had any kind of protection for the consumer for this type of tactic. Surprise Surprise it turns out it is  perfectly legal for them to charge what ever they want. No caps or any controls on how much they can raise the rates.
It is time for a revolution in this country against Insurance Companies.
Everyone should cancel their policies at one time and put these con artists out of business.
Jerry

Please use my name only as "Tony" I fear retribution from State Farm.

ROB'S NOTE: How strange is it that Tony would have to fear retribution from "a good neighbor"? Amazing. But read on:

I really need your help. Recently my daughter was in an accident with one of State Farm's insured. Their insured was not driving the vehicle, someone else was, and they backed into my daughter in a parking lot. Police refused to respond because it was private property. Thus began the perfect storm.

By the time the dust settled State Farm claimed that their driver had produced a "witness" who said their insured was in fact the one driving and that my daughter had rear ended them and was at fault.

State Farm made the decision to deny the claim and never even spoke to my daughter until I had contacted them and yelled until they did. They would take the word of a witness that their driver produced after the fact but would not even speak to the two witnesses who were in the car with my daughter when the accident occurred. And to this minute they refuse to even consider allowing me to file an appeal or do anything to assist. What really stinks is I have had my home owners policy with State Farm for 19 years, and a good chunk of that time had two homes with them. The damage to my daughter's car is slight and it would have been much cheaper for them to pay my claim then to lose me as a client, but oh well.

Here is my real question. Who is the advocate for people in my situation? All State Farm has to do is say no and no one will help. This is an outrage and very unfair. State Farm has dared me, literally, to take them to court. I know that if on some technicality I lost I would be liable for their legal fees as well as my own. I am sure they bank on that. I have contacted my state insurance commissioner's office and they have had the case for nearly two months and I can't even get a call back. I am afraid being too aggressive with them will cause me to lose the one last hope that I have.

Do you have any advice? This could be your wife or your daughter that this happens to. Doesn't State Farm feel any responsibility to try and find out what really happened or is it truly just about money? They won't consider obvious witnesses because this would force them into a position where they cannot just deny, deny, deny. I guess this is just a small taste of what those poor people in Katrina felt like when State Farm was sticking it to them.

ROB RESPONDS: Tony, all you can do is go public and NOT be intimidated. I'm no expert, but I agree with you that intimidation is what they rely on. Persistence can wear you down, but it can ALSO wear THEM down. I'd keep sending the letters and if necessary, consider small claims court. In California, the limit is/was $7500 -- and they never LOWER the limit. Have you tried that? Small claims judges also tend to bend over backwards to help out the well-documented, polite little guy.

Steve From Stafford Virginia: 

I filed a claim to state farm for water damage to my residence after a rubber grommet that surrounds the vent pipe on the roof was damaged, opened a gash on the seal, water came in for 8-9 straight hours, ruined upstairs bathroom, and coming to rest in lower living quarters under the pergo flooring. Residence is a Split level home lower part partially underground with sump pump. 

After the storm, a State Farm adjuster came over spent about 30 minutes pointing a flashlight at various parts of the damage and said those magic words that excludes them from paying out, "sub surface water damage." 

After spending time showing the guy how the water flowed he argued and flew out in a huff, Result, they only paid for the upper bathroom ceiling area. but absolutely will not cover the down stairs, living area. I explained my wife and I witnessed the water flow into the area, It didn't come down like in buckets, but a steady stream for 8-9 hrs. He explained he had a whole 10 years experience at this,  (Adjuster Stuff) He explained he doesn't see how that stream gathered that much in a volume of water. I turned to the deep sink, turned the water on a steady stream of water, and told him let that run on your floor for a while and see if water doesn't collect on your floor. He didn't hardly speak to me after that. 

The pergo flooring was only in one room, on the whole downstairs living quarters. The water level didn't rise above the quarter inch pergo flooring, there wasn't that much water Just enough to damage the edges of the floor. State farm Agent agreed with me, but was told to stay out of the argument...I explained we had additional storms with equal intensity with heavy rains on an already saturated ground with no further incident after fixing the roof. The water was clear rain water, not stained muddy ground water. State Farm only gave me a check for half the damage. The sump pump was working as always. the water in the lower lower quarters was rain water not sub surface ground water.

To everyone and anyone reading this post, you MUST know that whenever submitting a claim to State Farm, you must expect to appeal and go after your rightful settlement no matter what they tell you!  For reasons that are too boring to go into, we still have State Farm covering our home.  But watch this:

We recently had a pipe burst, flooding out lower floor and ruining the hardwood.  State Farm was very quick to send out one of their adjusters, a nice woman with a clipboard and a pencil.  The woman poked around, took measurements and left -- in about ten minutes.

Roughly a week later, I received a check for roughly six thousand dollars.  Nice, except that the damages were way higher than that.

I immediately called the State Farm adjuster, and faxed her a notice describing everything her "field agent" had missed, including three rooms and four walls that were heavily damaged.  But then I went even further, calling in floor and wall contractors to estimate the cost of repairs.  Each contractor came in with a bid three times higher than the State Farm amount.

I faxed those estimates to the State Farm offices, too.  They decided to send out their own contractor, who submitted his own estimate, which was only twice as high as their original.

Within four more weeks, I received another check from State Farm, which actually covered the damages in a non-fiction format.

Moral of the story:  Get everything documented, keep copies and show them you mean business.  It is, after all, just a business to them.

Rob,

Proceeding cautiously here! My wife and I are business owners in (withheld by Rob to prevent retribution from State Farm).

We are currently being withheld claim payment from a May13th 2007 burglary at our store. Not denied, they have claimed for 7 months they are investigating! Well we lost 17,000 thousand dollars worth of inventory from a 1 year old startup business that was doing extremely well. 

There (sic) failure to pay this claim has now forced us to shut down 1 brick and mortar store and we are in jeopardy of losing more. The real kick in the nuts here is my wife is visually disabled not 100% but she will be eventually due to eye condition. Its her business and DVR and the Bureau of the blind helped set her up for future self employment for the disabled.

The thief's (sic) stole her PC and wrecked other equipment that allows her to operate the business as normal despite her disability. This allows her to maintain records and prepare them for our accountant, do banking, inventories and other things a business owner would need to do. 

Now our good neighbor has been investigating claim, refuses to explain, what, why or anything. They keep requesting documents over and over knowing how hard this is on my wife without the equipment they are denying replacement of (special rider just for this equipment)

Now they have begun sending large bundles of our records they requested, re-copied in extra small legal text and tell my wife to legally confirm the accuracy of all records. There is so much more to tell you but i will need to find out a little more about you. I have documents, tape recordings and transcripts and have documented 7 months of this. we sat back and have let them proceed unabated but not unrecorded. Now its time to act!

I also run a network of websites and webstores and was going to do the same thing you are doing to our neighbor online, but am cautious due to wifes claim status. I have the ability to host video, tapes, documents, or anything else, and it cannot be shut down or spammed away. Several of our sites have good PR with google and the link power they have is a great publicity tool.We also have customer forums and the users love to spread information down the highway. 

Hope to hear back from you soon!

Jason & Judy

(If you would like to contact Jason, reply to Rob directly)

Jon has entire sites devoted to State Farm's "service"!

Hi, I think state farm is the worst; I can send you all my letters if you would like: they basically changed my APR rate of my credit card, Lied about a balance transfer and for my insurance they actually said they would cover something and turned around and did something else:)

http://www.statefarmstillsucks.com

Alexa submitted this link, noting that even Senator Trent Lott is suing State Farm over the way it seems to be dodging its responsiblities stemming from Hurrican Katrina. State Farm claims damage done by wind was actualy done by flood water. The article claims that even when State Farm agents agreed that damages were covered, State Farm refused to pay and actually fired the agents. Read more at http://www.consumeraffairs.com/news04/2005/katrina_lott.html.

Travis writes this adventure:

On Dec. 19, 2005, I was rear-ended by a State Farm insured. She was lost, in rush hour traffic, and too busy talking on her cell phone to worry too much about driving. She plowed her '92 Toyota Tercel into the rear of my '99 Dodge Neon. Neither her car nor mine were drivable. I had mine towed to a dealership with a body shop.

The following wednesday, I called State Farm to find out the status of the claim. NO CLAIM HAD BEEN FILED. Maybe their insured was still on the phone, who knows. So I let them know what happened, and they said they had to talk to their insured. Hours later that day, I got a call stating they were accepting responsibility for the accident, and that they would get someone out to look at my car. Finally, on January 3rd, they call back and tell me they're going to declare the car a total loss.

The woman explained to me the repair estimate was $3400, so they were going to cut me a check for $3700. I said "wait, I thought you just said the repairs were only thirty four hundred. Why would you give me MORE? She replied that THEY would be getting my car!

I explained that is not an option, since I owe more than that on the car, and it's under lien. She replied they are under "no legal obligation" to pay off what I owe the bank. I told her I was not interested in some kind of payoff, just FIX MY CAR. She rattled on something about when an estimate is within a certain percent of the "total loss" declaration, they can declare it a total loss. I again explained that I owe more than their "payoff" and cannot afford to pay a thousand dollars to a bank for a car I would no longer possess. She simply said that it's not their problem.

Then it came to light WHY they were willing to give me $3700 for the car- they fully expect ME to BUY BACK the car from them, which would mean they'd only have to write a check for $3100 (the difference between the retail and salvage retail). I told her she needs to have someone call me back that is more qualified to answer my questions. I've yet to hear back on it.

While I have finally gone into my own pocket to repair my shower, I have not given up in my fight against State Farm Insurance. Neither, apparently, have FORMER STATE FARM AGENTS....check out THIS nightmare from Fulvio Manetti, a State Farm agent who got royally screwed by his own company:

I am a retired (early retirement because I could not take it any more!!)State Farm agent and I have seen first hand the wrong things underwriting and claim were doing to the public. When I retired, after 25 years, my retirement pay was given, without due recourse, to my ex wife and I was left to survive with my SS income.

They have millions of dollars stashed away in a retirement fund which only the few privileged have access to it.

Arbitrarily they estimate claim reserves to the disadvantage of policy holders.

The powers to be could say that mine are ''sour grapes'' but I have always served my policy holders with integrity and I have always been one of the better agents. I could write a book about the underhanded dealings of State Farm agents and management toward the public.

State farm sucks and should be investigated for their dealings with agents and policyholders.

Fulvio Manetti
Retired ''Satefarm sucks'' agent

Wow, Mark (name witheld by request) reports that State Farm ripped him off in an automobile incident. What's with these people? Read this:

"I was in an automobile accident with one of their policyholders on 3/9/2004. No question that it was his fault, he was issued a ticket citing him at fault. State Farm decided that they would scrap my recently completed 1984 restored Corvette (new motor and all) and offered me $5400 for the car. The NADA book value for a 1984 Vette in average condition is $17,100. I provided receipts for $9000 worth of work done on the car in the past 2 years and they increased their offer to $6000. They towed my car off to a scrap yard without my permission. I am open to suggestion regarding how to make the cheap bastards pay the Fair Market Value for my destroyed car. They do not listen to the fact that you cannot replace a 1984 in like new condition for $6000."

Like a good neighbor, eh?

It's been a tough battle, but people are still sending in their stories about how State Farm sucks. This one is from Amie:

Hi there.

I found your website via Planet Feedback, and I am letting you know that you are not alone.

I canceled my policy with State Farm more than a year ago after they hiked my monthly premiums nearly $100.00. No warning, no letter, no phone call nothing; when I called my agent, she knew nothing about it, and I got the runaround for a month before I finally said "screw it" and found a different carrier.

I am now fighting insurance companies on their practice of illegal discrimination due to age. State and federal law prohibits this, and if you want to help me out with this, or can in any way, please let me know.

Thanks for sharing your story!

Amie Thompson

Back in the saddle after New Years, because it's impossible to get anything done between December 15 and the Super Bowl. Sometimes I think that America has too many holidays. I can't get anything done. Then again, when I see the kind of incompetence at State Farm, it's no wonder. If one of the nation's largest companies can sit there fat and happy without working, I guess everyone else thinks they can.

In the meantime, Mark from Tennessee wrote this heart-wrenching story about what his parents had to endure with State Farm:

My parents live in Hermitage, Tennessee, a suburb of Nashville. On April
16th 1998, a tornado went through Nashville and Davidson County, causing
extensive damage to my parents neighborhood.

Fortunately, neither of my parents were injured, but they sustained losses
in property. This area has many old, massive trees, which can easily exceed
8 feet in circumfrence. Their detached garage was crushed by a large tree,
roofing was ripped away, and over 10 large trees were twisted, uprooted, or
blown over, some directly onto the house itself. A man down the street had
one crash through his roof and pin him in his recliner until the rescue
squad was able to saw him out, unharmed. There was no power to the area for
days following the storm.

Although I dont have access to the immediate lies that State Farm first gave
them, they were definately NOT a "good neighbor". The REAL good neighbors
stepped up to the plate to help clear the roads and driveways of debris,
etc. State Farm first refused to pay for damage to the garage, but
persistance by my parents got them to pony up a portion of the cost after a
long fight. Then, State Farm would not pay for the removal of the blown
down trees and limbs, even when they obviously were damaged to the point
that they threaten (and CONTINUE to threaten) the roof of the home. My
parents had to foot the bill for much of their damage.

My parents were patrons of State Farm for over 30 years without a single
claim prior to the tornado. Once the storm hit, State Farm seemed to enter
"damage control mode" and was unhospitable to many of the storm victims.

They have many photos of the damage, and the results.

A pox be upon thee, State Farm.

Another day, another form letter. Picareli sent another one, acknowledging the inquiry from the California Department of Insurance. At least we know that State Farm is in their system.

The next few weeks are going to be tough, seeing as how everyone goes on vacation for Christmas and New Years. I'm going to take some time off, as well, but will be using the time to gather more media and legal ammunition.

Team Leader Picareli called again. I have no idea why he called, other than to ask me if the letter I sent (last week) contained any "new information." I wasn't sure what to tell him. That more state, federal and local agencies had been contacted?

Again, he asked me to fax him the letter. At this point, I felt it only fair to ask him why, after the horrible way State Farm has treated us, should we do anything to make his life easier?

The only interesting part of the conversation was his admitting that they did not perform a thorough investigation. He admits it. He said, "Judging by the evidence, we're making a reasonable assumption..." I pointed out that it's exactly that -- his assumption -- that's screwing things up. I also pointed out that if they were to actually inspect the damage, they wouldn't have to rely on assumption.

Once again, the man resorted to reading me chapter and verse from the State Farm Avoidance and Denial Handbook.

We're looking at attorneys now....

Winding my way through the web, I'm finding all kinds of people with similar stories, where State Farm ripped them off for similar circumstances:

"Jim of Plant City FL (7/14/03):
Our pool drain pipe busted, causing all the water to drain from our pool and the walls and floor to bulge. State Farm sent geologists and engineers out to drill. The engineer determined that the breaking of the drain pipe was caused by the sudden collapse of dirt and slurry under the pool caused by an artesian well and limestone. State Farm denied our claim by stating that the drain pipe broke because of "normal wear and tear." We have hired an attorney and are seeking mediation and possible legal action if our pool is not replaced."

There's no artesian well on the second floor of my house, I promise you. What you have here is a sudden break obviously NOT caused by wear and tear. State Farm's response is typical. They're trying to bury this guy.

http://www.consumeraffairs.com/insurance/statefarm_home.html lists a fair number of stories about consumers' plight with State Farm. It's a very fair list: sometimes the consumers are out of line. This one, however, hit home.

Makes you wonder why State Farm, a Fortune 500 company with 2002 revenues of over $42 billion (with a "B") can't tend to business.

If you have a minute and REALLY want to get freaked out, read this one:

"Breanna of York PA (7/11/03):
On June 7, 2003 our basement flooded to over a foot of water. We immediately called a plumber to come help us with the problem. We then called State Farm to ask what we need to do next to get the water out of the basement. (Note: our basement has two big rooms - one furnished, one not). The State Farm rep we spoke with was David R. He "authorized" us to call a company called Service Master to come to the house and start the process of cleaning out the basement.

So we called Service Master and they came over and pumped between 3,000-4,000 gallons of water out of our basement. This is not including what the plumber had already pumped out. Just to remind you, the only reason Service Master is at our home, is because State Farm authorized them to be there. So they continue to do their job and pump out water and take up the carpet. We were never told, by ANYONE, this would not be a valid claim, therefore we assumed everything Service Master was doing was routine procedure. We were told by State Farm (David) that Service Master's services would be free. (And if you listen to the recording State Farm has of that conversation, you will find this to be true).

But when Service Master was finished, they informed us that we were to pay them our deductible ($500) and then State Farm would take care of the rest. So we went ahead and paid them the $500, although it seemed fishy. This all happened on a Saturday night, so we had to wait until Monday for State Farm to call us and give us our claim number. They called Monday and informed us that our claim will not be covered and we have to pay for the remainder of Service Master's fee's (which ended up being over $2,000). Needless to say, I was furious. I called State Farm and spoke with our agent, Trish Howser, and told her of the situation. She was no help at all.

I then spoke to another State Farm Claims rep and she told me that they (State Farm) never told us to call Service Master and also told us that this claim would never be valid. She also said that Service Master told us this claim would not be valid as well. (Service Master never said that - they actually quoted us around $8,000-$10,000 worth of damage - I have that conversation on video tape so I CAN prove them wrong). Everything this lady was telling me was a lie, so I told her the gentleman's name we spoke with and had her listen to the recording of that conversation. She called back and said that I was right and that State Farm did authorize us to call Service Master. But she denies they told us it was free. (Surprise! Another State Farm lie). So she told me they are going to keep the $500 deductible for Service Master but then State Farm will pay the rest. Which they did - over $1500.

The problem is, we have over $10,00 worth of damage to our basement not including our personal belongings, furniture, etc. My question is, how can State Farm pay for some of a claim, but not all of it? How can you take responsibility for half? I just don't understand. I called our rep (Mia B) and told her that this was ridiculous and I expect our carpet to be paid for as well as our electricity bill, at the very least. Service Master ripped up our carpet, put it on their truck, and threw it away. So we have no carpet now. They are only supposed to lift the carpet up and dry it. Not take it and throw it away. I asked Mia why we are not covered for this damage and she told me that sump pumps are not covered in our policy. Nowhere in the policy I have, is there an exclusion for sump pumps.

State Farm doesn't even know why our basement flooded. Mia is STILL trying to get in touch with our plumber who was here that night to see what caused the flood. It has been over a month now and that tells me State Farm is not trying very hard. I call her each week to see what is going on, and she keeps putting me off. I am in the process of writing a letter to the claims department, hoping for a response. How can State Farm say they are not covering a claim without even knowing what has happened? Mia said that she would come out to the house to inspect, but that hasn't happened yet either."

Like a good neighbor, eh?

A good thing happened today. The State Attorney General's office sent me a letter with a form for me to fill out. It was a follow up form, inquiring as to whether my case had been resolved or was still pending. It asked for all the information again, which I filled in and sent back to the AG's office. It was worth the 37¢ stamp to keep me in the system.

Meanwhile, I got ANOTHER call from Team Manager Picardi of State Farm. Now, I get it: Every time a state, local or Federal agency gets my letter, they send a copy to him. I suspect that flags him to call the policyholder so that his logs can show that he responded. So the guy calls me. Again, for no reason, other to read me chapter and verse out of the State Farm cheer book.

This time, I thank him for calling and let him know that unless State Farm is willing to investigate the damage and honor their policy, there's really no point wasting his -- or my -- time. He admits as much as hangs up.

An hour later, there's a voicemail for me from -- you guessed it -- Team Manager Picardi, asking me to please fax him the letter I sent to his office. Then he calls my office again to request the same thing.

Gee, maybe now he understands what it's like to be kept waiting. Hope my delay doesn't infringe on his Christmas shopping.....as far as I'm concerned, he can wait for the U.S. postal service just like everyone else. Grrrrrrr.

Finally, I need to go on record and document something else that's really weird. State Farm has issued me a check to cover the hole they tore in my ceiling. It's check #1-23-026431 for $479.92. That's fine. What's weird is that the Coverage Description on the check is coded for "Water/Freezing - Building". At least it documents the Loss Date as August 27, 2003.

Yesterday I mailed off the following letter to our Team Manager at State Farm. I wonder if they even read these things. I know that they're incredibly anal about their faxes. For example, a policyholder cannot fax anything directly to an adjuster. At State Farm, the fax must go to their central office for scanning and then be forwarded eletronically to the adjuster. Which means it can take up to 3 days for your adjuster to receive a fax that arrives in two minutes.

Sort of defeats the whole purpose of faxing, no? It's the same with their letters. Even though this genius works in Westlake Village, the letter has to be sent to Bakersfield. You're probably reading this before he is....

Here's my latest response to State Farm:

"December 6, 2003

Richard Picarelli
STATE FARM INSURANCE
P.O. Box 21330
Bakersfield, CA 93390-9819


Dear Mr. Picareli:

In your correspondence of December 3, 2003, you and your “investigators” once again fail to grasp the reality of the circumstances involved in our claim 75-M368-089.

In that letter, you once again mistakenly conclude that 'the damage to your home was a result of a continuous or repeated leak due to a deteriorated shower pan.'

Once again, let me remind you that we are NOT claiming damages as a result of any shower pan leak. We are claiming the sudden break in the shower pan, which two independent experts have confirmed was sudden, not the result of damage over time.

Your letter asks that we forward additional information:

Claims and complaints against you have been filed with the California State Department of Insurance, the Better Business Bureau, the California State Attorney’s Office. A public website has been launched to collect similar case studies involving State Farm via http://www.rippedoffbystatefarm.org. And investigative reporters across the country are following this case – including your correspondence -- via http://rippedoffbystatefarm.blogspot.com.

I hereby reiterate my demand that State Farm find coverage for repairing the shower pan as this sudden break is most definitely covered by our policy.


Sincerely,

Rob Frankel"

Holy cow, take a look at this story submitted by Diane in Florida. When you start reading, it sounds like just another story. But it's not "just another story." This time, State Farm actually said they'd cover a leak, then reneged, then eventually paid for the leak! This is the perfect story about how you absolutely must hammer State Farm over their heads until they wake up and do the right thing:

"I will tell you my story, just DO NOT Give them my name. I live in the state of Florida so I'm basically stuck. We can't change companies as NO ONE wants to write us in Florida. I have had my home, car and boat insurance with State Farm for over 20 years.

"I had another insurance company prior. We kept hearing water running, and our water bill went sky high. I did not see any leaks or anything but I called a plumber. Seems we had a Leak in the copper pipe (UNDER THE CONCRETE FLOOR) under the house. They had to jack hammer thru the floor to repair it. The insurance company REFUSED To pay, I was SO MAD.

"I called around, and ended up with State Farm, who assured me they DID cover leaks under the floor. 

"Well, about a year later, the SAME thing happened again but in another place. I called the leak detection team, and sure enough they found another leak. Before we did anything else we called State Farm. They sent out an adjuster (about a week later). Of course all this time, we were having to run outside to turn OFF the water and on when we needed it It was a real nuisance.

"Finally, the adjuster got back to me and told me that was NOT a covered expense. Because pipes were NORMAL Maintenance. I was LIVID and asked what kind of NORMAL maintenance people would do on pipes underneath a house. He could not answer that. Then I said well what if I just DO NOT fix it and it causes a sink hole, and the house falls in, and he said then that would not be covered because I knew of that and didn't exercise reasonable care.

"We ended up getting a plumber to replumb the entire house so the pipes would NOT be under the floor anymore. Meantime, we filed a protest and a complaint with the insurance commissioners office. We were really very mad because we ASKED about this specific condition BEFORE we chose State Farm and we were told it WAS covered. I put that into the complaint as well.

"On their behalf, I would say the Agent that sold us the policy did admit to them that he had told us that was a covered item. Due to that, and our consistent follow up, with calling, writing and complaining about 8 or 9 months later they agreed to pay for the "repair". The only thing is we could not wait that time without fixing so we had to replumb the house , and they said that was NOT covered. HOWEVER, we finally got them to agree to paying about $1200 which was what it had cost us for the prior one, from the other company. 

"I was NOT at all happy with the way they stalled and put that off. For the money we pay for the insurance, I feel things should be covered without such a runaround. 

"Being in the state of Florida I have no recourse but to stay with them, because no other companies will cover us. If you get dropped you have to go to the state and pay astronomical rates.

"So that's my ONE claim experience in 20 years, but they NEVER have a problem raising my insurance every year.

"If I can help with anything else let me know. Regards, Diane"