Leigh weighs in with this unbelievable incident...read it all the way through:
In 2006, my 18-year-old daughter and 13-year-old son were in a 5 mph fender bender with a lady (I’ll call her Donna) insured through State Farm. In a construction site, she changed lanes without signaling and hit my daughter’s front right bumper. My daughter was already in the lane. Since the damage amounted to a cracked signal light on my daughter’s car, and no damage that the naked eye could see on Donna’s car, she left the scene before police could be contacted. The car my daughter was driving was not hers, but belonged to her aunt. We went along merrily until one month later when I get a phone call from Donna saying that, in fact, she DID have damage to her bumper in the amount of 1,800 and wanted me to write her a check. How she got our number, I don’t know as there was no information exchanged at the scene. Being suspicious, I refused to pay as I felt that doing so would admit liability. I suggested it be reported to the insurance company. We get no calls or anything, so I assume nothing was reported at her end. Almost a year later, we get a call from State Farm letting us know that there was nearly $15,000 worth of medical bills and car damage done to their insured. How could this happen? Her back bumper was just tapped, and she was driving an Econoline van—may daughter was driving a Honda Civic. Her back window was smashed in, her bumper seared in half—damage that could only happen if she was hit by someone going at a high rate of speed. State Farm advised they will file a lawsuit to seek reimbursement from us. We got an attorney. He says we don’t have a leg to stand on since there were no photos, the Honda was long sold off, and there was no police report. We head to arbitration. The arbitrator sides with Donna who is older. There was no evidence to support my daughter’s claim that SHE got run into, and they can’t take her brother’s testimony because he is related. We threaten to go before a jury. Our attorney advises us that State Farm has very high-powered attorneys and it could be costly for us to fight it. We cut our losses and took it in the backside. We have been paying $200 per month ever since and have our balance down to $1,400 (basically interest at this point). I did later find out that State Farm indeed had photos of my daughter’s car. She was working when they came by to ask her if they could photograph her car one evening. Strangely enough, they denied having the photos and wouldn’t let us see the file unless we got a subpoena. Long story short…if you are ever hit by a State Farm insured, make sure the police are there, you take photos and get statements. They are a no-fault company and will pay their insured whatever, then will come after the other party full on. Until I go to my grave, I will find every opportunity to smear them.